What is the difference between demonic possession and obsession?

Qual a diferença entre possessão e obsessão demoníaca?

By · Updated

Therefore, let the exorcist not proceed to the celebration of an exorcism unless he has ascertained, with moral certainty, that the one to be exorcized is indeed possessed (obsessed) by a demon and, if possible, with his consent. (From De exorcismis et supplicationibus quibusdam, n. 16)

The difference lies in the place and manner of the demon’s action. In possession, the demon exercises a despotic control over the body, and in moments of crisis, moves and speaks through it, without the person being able to prevent it. The soul remains hers, and during the crisis, the person is not responsible for what the body does or says. In obsession, the attack is directed at the imagination and memory: the person finds themselves invaded by thoughts and images that they feel are strange and that they cannot dispel. The intelligence and free will are not directly affected, though they suffer an indirect assault, and therefore an imposed idea, which the person rejects, is not a sin.

This is the distinction that today is used by the International Association of Exorcists, and many exorcists follow it. However, it is important to know where it comes from, because the words “obsession” and “possession” did not always mean the same thing, and the Church’s Ritual does not use them as we do today.

## What the Ritual Says

The current ritual for exorcisms, the De exorcismis et supplicationibus quibusdam (1999, amended edition of 2004), speaks of the person in need of help with two Latin words: vexatus, “tormented,” and obsessus, literally “besieged.” In §10 it states that in cases of “peculiaris vexationis seu obsessionis,” “a peculiar torment or obsession,” the Church “fideli vexato seu obsesso plura adiutoria praebet, ut a vexatione seu obsessione liberetur,” “offers to the faithful tormented or besieged various aids, so that they may be freed from torment or obsession” (De exorcismis, §10). The Ritual does not define or distinguish the two terms and uses them together, linked by “seu” or “or,” to designate the one in need of the exorcism. In §14 it uses obsessus and vexatus for the same person. The Portuguese and Italian translations, and according to a CNBB (Brazilian Conference of Bishops) aid, also the Brazilian translation, have written here “possession,” and it is for this reason that some read in the Ritual a distinction between oppression and possession that Latin does not make.

The same holds true for the Rituale Romanum of 1614 (cited in the Roman edition of 1617). Its title on exorcisms is “De exorcizandis obsessis a daemonio,” and the first paragraph speaks of the priest “vexatos a daemone exorcizaturus,” “who is about to exorcise those tormented by the demon.” In the vocabulary of the Ritual, obsessus is one who needs exorcism. The International Association of Exorcists itself observes that the Ritual, “in continuity with the RR, does not concern itself with offering a definition of what indicates with the terms of vexatio and obsessio” (AIE, 2022, n. 049, p. 60).

# The Language of Exorcists: Four Types

For practical discernment, the AIE has established its own terminology, which, according to the Association itself, the Italian Episcopal Conference has adopted in the presentation of the Italian translation of the Rite (AIE, 2022, n. 047, p. 59). It distinguishes between possession, obsession, and vexation, when the demon’s action is exercised directly upon a person, and infestation, when it has as its object places and things given into human use (n. 046 and 070).

Possession: “The action by which a malicious spirit is able to exercise a despotic control over the human body, to the point that, during certain moments of ‘crisis’, it can move and/or speak through the body of the possessed person, without the victim being able to prevent it, even when they maintain consciousness of what is happening” (AIE, 2022, n. 052, p. 62). What the demon blocks is the dominion that the self exercises over the body through the faculties, and not the faculties of the soul itself (n. 055, p. 64).

Obsession: the action that aggresses and torments the inner man, in the psychic sphere. “Such aggression is not directed directly at the intellect and free will of the person, since these two faculties are impervious to any creature” (AIE, 2022, n. 061, p. 66). What is affected are the internal senses, especially imagination and memory, and the victim “is unable to repel them,” that is, the images, sounds, and sensations that are imposed upon him (n. 062-063).

Distress: physical assault, “without thereby ipso facto acquiring possession of the body that is being tormented, which consequently remains under the normal control of human intellect and will” (AIE, 2022, n. 066, p. 69).

Infestation: an action directed “to places or to things given for the use of man, including animals” (AIE, 2022, n. 070, p. 70).

The AI itself warns that the boundaries between these species “are not always clear” (n. 048). Nor do all authors use the same terms. Adolphe Tanquerey, in his classic manual of spiritual theology, knew of only two: obsession, in which the devil “besieges, so to speak, the soul from without,” “circles, so to speak, the soul from outside,” and possession, in which “takes up residence in the body” (TANQUEREY, [1928], n. 1531). The Spanish exorcist José Antonio Fortea prefers to avoid the term “obsession” because in ancient literature “diabolic obsession” meant “demonic siege,” and the term, he says, “could not be more conducive to confusion” (FORTEA, 2012, p. 123). The framework of four species is, therefore, a vocabulary to aid in discernment, useful and adopted by the AI and by several authors, and not a division made by the Ritual.

Moral Responsibility

In possession, the person is not responsible for what they do or say during the crisis. Fortea writes that “the possessed is not, morally speaking, responsible for what he does or says during the trances of possession,” but that he is “perfectly free and therefore responsible for what he does outside of those trances,” “the possession is not responsible, morally speaking, for what he does or says during the trances of possession,” but is “perfectly free and therefore responsible for what he does outside of those trances” (FORTEA, 2012, p. 97).

In obsession, the will is not taken, but the person suffers thoughts that they did not choose. Tanquerey reminds the spiritual director «that there is no sin without consent», «that there is no sin without consent» (TANQUEREY, [1928], n. 1535). And the Italian presentation of the Rite, cited by AIE, states of these phenomena that «they certainly cause great sufferings, but, in themselves, they do not turn one away from God and do not have the gravity of a sin» (AIE, 2022, n. 057, p. 65). To suffer this is not, in itself, a sin. The Ritual distinguishes this form of power from the devil from that «quae per originale peccatum in homine derivatur, quae peccatum est», «which derives in man from original sin, which is a sin» (De exorcismis, n. 10).

Signs and Prudence

The Ritual of 1614 indicated three signs of possession, and that of 1999 repeats them: “to speak in an unknown language with many words, or to understand him who speaks, to reveal distant and hidden things, to manifest forces above the nature of age or condition” (De Exorcismis, n. 16). It adds that these signs “may give some indication,” but they should not necessarily be taken as coming from the devil. Therefore, it directs attention also to moral and spiritual signs, such as a violent aversion to God, to the name of Jesus, to the Virgin Mary and the saints, to the Church, to the word of God and to the sacraments, and finally, to the relation of all the signs with faith and spiritual combat (n. 16).

The first rule is not to believe readily. The Ritual directs the exorcist not to assume easily that one suffering from a disease, especially psychic, is possessed by the devil, and that, to determine whether to use the rite, he should consult “experts in spiritual matters and, where necessary, in the science of medicine and psychiatry, who have sensitivity to spiritual things” (De Exorcismis, nos. 14 and 17). The Catechism says the same: “It is quite different when it comes to diseases, especially psychic ones, whose treatment depends on medical science. Therefore, it is important to verify before celebrating the exorcism if it is a case of the malign spirit or a disease” (CCC 1673).

A study recommended by the Sacred Congregation for Doctrine in 1975 summarizes the Church’s attitude: “When speaking of a possible diabolic intervention, the Church always makes room, as with a miracle, for the critical demand. In this matter, it demands reserve and prudence” (FEDE…, 1975).

The boundary with psychiatry

The collaboration between the exorcist and the physician is not a modern concession. Already the Ritual of 1614 commanded to distinguish the possession of those who suffer “vel atra bile, vel morbo aliquo”, “of black bile or some disease” (RITUALE…, 1617, p. 342), and Tanquerey advised, in doubt, to consult a Christian physician (TANQUEREY, [1928], n. 1534). In Brazil, in 1963, João Carvalhal Ribas presented to the Paulista Medical School his thesis of chair The Boundaries of Demonology and Psychiatry. In it he studied the causes of mental disturbances, supernatural, biological and psychosocial, and then the clinical forms, temptation, obsession and diabolic possession, giving to each one the demonological and psychiatric interpretation (RIBAS, 1963, p. 55-104).

Today, there are psychiatrists who work alongside exorcists. The Argentine Héctor de Ezcurra has drafted a guide to discernment with comparative charts for twelve clinical situations, in each of which he seeks to answer the question: “How to distinguish this psychopathological condition from possession, vexation, obsession, or demonic infestation?” (EZCURRA, [20–], p. 2). And the AIE (International Association of Exorcists) acknowledges that most people who present themselves to exorcists as “obsessed” actually suffer from phenomena of purely pathological origin (AIE, 2022, n. 065, p. 68).

The exorcist Francesco Bamonte addresses the same boundary and reminds us that the extraordinary action of the demon can intersect with illness, which necessitates distinguishing between healing and liberation (BAMONTE, [20–], pp. 131-135). Not everything that is ill is the work of evil, and not everything that is the work of evil is healed with medicine.

A Serious Objection: Rahner and Kasper

It would be dishonest to present the distinction as peaceful throughout all theology. Karl Rahner, in the entry “Besessenheit” in the theological dictionary he published with Herbert Vorgrimler in 1961, wrote that, from a religious perspective, “it is neither possible nor particularly important to draw a precise boundary between demonic possession and natural illness, especially because natural illness can also be a symptom of possession or a breach through which possession can enter” (RAHNER apud TERRA, 1996, p. 266). He added that there is no radical dilemma between exorcism and medicine, “all the more so that even in the most natural illness, every Christian must pray to obtain healing” (RAHNER apud TERRA, 1996, p. 266). He acknowledged that a phenomenon may deserve the name of “possession” “in a strictly theological sense,” as a manifestation of “the fundamental dominion of demonic forces,” but concluded that it is neither necessary nor possible to distinguish adequately the demonic influence from pathological predispositions (TERRA, 1996, p. 216 and 266-267).

In 1978, Walter Kasper, who did not exclude a priori the possibility of possession, held that there are no unambiguous theological criteria to verify it, and called for a revision of the criteria in the Ritual of 1614: «The intrinsic criteria, linked to certain extraordinary phenomena that the Roman Ritual of 1614 lists for the determination of demonic possession, therefore require an urgent and radical revision», «the extrinsic criteria, linked to certain extraordinary phenomena that the Roman Ritual of 1614 lists for the verification of demonic possession, thus require an urgent and radical revision» (KASPER, 1983, p. 76).

The objection has merit, and the 1999 Ritual goes in part in the same direction. It preserved the ancient signs, but declared that they may offer “some indication” and should not be necessarily attributed to the devil, added moral and spiritual signs, and directed consultation with doctors and psychiatrists. What it did not abandon was the requirement of moral certainty before the major exorcism (n. 16). The distinction protects both parties: the ill person, from a rite that will not cure him, and the one tormented by the devil, from a treatment that will not set him free.

What the Church does in one case and in another

Against temptation, the Ritual recommends prayer, sobriety, and frequent confession (De Exorcismis, n. 9). For those suffering from the extraordinary action of the devil, the Church offers “plura adiutoria,” “various aids” (n. 10), and the AIE reminds that here ordinary means alone are not sufficient (AIE, 2022, n. 049 f, p. 61). Among these aids is the solemn or major exorcism, a liturgical action reserved to the priest who has received special and express permission from the Ordinary of the place, generally the diocesan bishop (De Exorcismis, n. 11 and 13, cf. Can. 1172, CCC 1673). The Ritual only allows it when there is moral certainty that the exorcized is “reversa daemone obsessum,” “in fact obsessed by the devil” (n. 16). Exorcists debate whether this applies only to possession or to all forms of extraordinary action.

The deprecatory prayer of the rite describes soberly the condition of the tormented: “the ancient adversary torments him fiercely.” It asks God to free him, invoking the prayers of the Virgin Mary, “whose Son, dying on the cross, crushed the head of the ancient serpent,” and the intercession of the archangel Saint Michael (De Exorcismis, n. 61). Thus, the liturgy of liberation bears at its center the promise of Genesis 3:15: Christ’s victory over evil, to which his Mother is united.

## Frequently Asked Questions

What are the species of the extraordinary action of the demon?

According to the terminology of the International Association of Exorcists, four types exist: possession (control of the body during moments of crisis), obsession (assault on imagination and memory, without directly affecting intelligence and will), vexation (physical assaults, without possession of the body), and infestation (places, things, and animals). The Church’s Ritual does not make this distinction and uses obsessus and vexatus for the same person.

Does a possessed person sin when they are in crisis?

No. During a crisis, one is not responsible for what the body does or says. Outside of a crisis, one is free and responsible like any other person. And to suffer the extraordinary action of the devil is not, in itself, a sin.

How is possession distinguished from a psychiatric illness?

By the prior exclusion of natural causes, with the assistance of physicians and psychiatrists, and through the examination of the signs indicated by the Ritual: unknown tongues, knowledge of hidden things, strength beyond one’s condition, accompanied by moral and spiritual signs such as a vehement aversion to the sacred. The Ritual warns that these signs may provide “some indication” and should not necessarily be attributed to the devil.

Do all theologians accept this distinction?

Without reservation. Karl Rahner believed that, from a religious perspective, it is neither possible nor particularly important to draw a precise boundary between possession and illness, although he acknowledged possession in a strictly theological sense. Walter Kasper called for a review of the criteria established in 1614. The Ritual of 1999 goes in part in the same direction, but maintained the requirement of moral certainty before performing a major exorcism.

## References

International Association of Exorcists. Portuguese Linguistic Secretariat. Guidelines for the Ministry of Exorcism in Light of the Current Ritual. Translation by Rubens Miraglia Zani. Introduction by Pedro Carlos Cipollini. Brasília: CNBB Editions, 2022.

BAMONTE, Francesco. How to Recognize the Crafty Father of Lies: Demonic Possessions and Exorcisms. [São Paulo]: Ave-Maria, [20–].

Catechism of the Catholic Church. n. 1673.

EZCURRA, Héctor de. The Differential Diagnosis Between Psychopathological Disorders and the Extraordinary Action of the Devil. [No location: no publisher], [20–]. Coursework 05. Translation of a lecture.

Christian Faith and Demonology. Study recommended by the Sacred Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith, June 26, 1975. Available at: https://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_19750626_fede-cristiana-demonologia_it.html.

FORTEA, José Antonio. Summa daemoniaca: A Treatise on Demonology and a Manual for Exorcists. 9th ed. Zaragoza: Dos Latidos, 2012.

KASPER, Walter. The theological problem of evil. In: KASPER, Walter and LEHMANN, Karl (eds.). Devil, demons, possession: on the reality of evil. Translated by Dino Pezzetta. Brescia: Queriniana, 1983. (Journal of Theology, 149).

Ribas, John Carvalhal. The Boundaries of Demonology and Psychiatry. 1963. Thesis (Competition for Professor of Clinical Psychiatry), Paulista School of Medicine, São Paulo, 1963.

The Roman Rite established by decree of the Second Vatican Ecumenical Council, promulgated by authority of Pope John Paul II. On Exorcisms and Certain Prayers. Edited text revised. Vatican City: Vatican Press, 2004. Re-issued 2005.

The Roman Ritual of Paul V, at the command of the Supreme Pontiff. Rome: From the Apostolic Press, 1617. pp. 342-377: On Exorcising Those Possessed by a Demon.

Tanqueray, Adolphe. A Concise Summary of Ascetic and Mystical Theology. 7th ed. Paris: Desclée, [1928].

Earth, John Evangelist Martins. The Angelology of Karl Rahner in Light of His Hermeneutical Principles. Aparecida: Sanctuary, 1996.

Would you like to study angelology and demonology in depth?

This article comes from the Locus Mariologicus library. The postgraduate specialisation in Angelology and Demonology (360 hours, fully online) studies angels and demons in Scripture, the Fathers and the Magisterium, with a whole area on practical demonology, exorcism and deliverance prayer. The new class begins on 18 January 2027. Classes are taught in Portuguese.

See the Angelology and Demonology programme

Responses