Do the angels have free will? What did the Fourth Lateran Council define?

By Prof. Dr. Daniel C. Afonso · Updated
Diabolus enim et alii daemones a Deo quidem natura creati sunt boni, sed ipsi per se facti sunt mali.“For Satan and the other demons were created by God good by nature, but they became evil by their own choice.” (Fourth Lateran Council, 1215, DS 800)
Yes, angels have free will. The Catechism of the Catholic Church explicitly states: “Angels and men, intelligent and free creatures, are to reach their ultimate end by free choice and by a love that gives preference. They can therefore stray. In fact, they sinned” (CCC 311). And the Fourth Council of Lateran, in 1215, teaches what makes this freedom undeniable: demons were created good and became evil by their own choice. Only he who is capable of choosing can become evil.
What does the Council teach?
The first chapter of the Fourth Council of Lateran, the profession of faith beginning with “Firmiter credimus,” was written against the Cathars, known as Albigensians in southern France, many of whom held that a rival principle to God was the source of evil. Against them, the Council confesses one God, “creator omnium visibilium et invisibilium, spiritualium et corporalium,” “creator of all things visible and invisible, spiritual and corporal,” and adds: “Diabolus enim et alii daemones a Deo quidem natura creati sunt boni, sed ipsi per se facti sunt mali. Homo vero diaboli suggestione peccavit,” “for the Devil and other demons were indeed created by God good by nature, but they themselves became evil. Man, in turn, sinned through the suggestion of the Devil” (DS 800).
Three statements follow in sequence. Demons were created, therefore they are not an eternal principle. They were created good by nature, therefore the angelic nature is not evil. They became evil by themselves, therefore there was a personal act. The Council does not use the expression “free will,” but the free will of angels is the necessary consequence of what defines them. Angelo Amato, in the volume Angeli e demoni, concludes: “the cause of their transformation from good to evil is to be attributed exclusively to their free will” (AMATO, 1992, p. 127).
Before Lateran
The heretic Priscillianists did not invent this doctrine. In 447, Pope Saint Leo the Great (the authenticity of the letter was questioned by K. Künstle) responded to them, who claimed that the devil had never been good: “Where would the devil be good, if he had remained in what he was? But since he used his natural excellence evil and ‘did not remain in the truth’ (John 8:44), he did not pass to a contrary substance, but descended… from the supreme good, to which he was bound” (LEON I, Letter to Turibius, DS 286).
The First Council of Braga, in 561, condemned those who said that the devil was not formerly a good angel created by God, “but himself the principle and substance of evil, as Manichaeus and Priscillianus said,” (Braga I, can. 7, DS 457). And in 1208, seven years before Lateran, the profession of faith prescribed for the converted Valdensian Durando of Huesca, transmitted by Innocent III, stated: “We believe that the devil became evil not by condition, but by will” (DS 797).
Freedom and Intelligence
Saint Thomas Aquinas gives the reason why angels are free. A arrow moves because it is moved by another. An animal acts by a judgment given to it by nature. Only he who has intelligence knows the universal reason of good and can judge freely: “Wherever there is intellect, there is free will. And thus it is clear that free will exists in angels, even more excellent than in men, as also the intellect” (TOMAS DE AQUINAS, Summa Theologiae I, q. 59, a. 3). Angels choose, Thomas says further, not after a long deliberation, but “per subitam acceptionem veritatis,” “by a sudden apprehension of truth” (ad 1).
The same idea is found in the Conimbricensem Cursus, the great philosophy course of the Jesuits at the College of Coimbra: “Free will (liberum arbitrium) is the highest expression of the intellectual nature” (CARVALHO, 2020, p. 263). And Saint John Damascene defines the angel as “οὐσία νοερά, ἀεικίνητος, αὐτεξούσιος […]”, “an intellectual substance, always in motion, endowed with free will […]” (JOÃO DAMASCENO, De fide orthodoxa II, 3, PG 94, 865).
The Fall: Pride, not Nature
How could a good creature created by God sin? Saint Augustine replies that the cause of the misery of the evil angels is their departure from God and turning in upon themselves, and that this vice is called pride (De civitate Dei, XII, 6, PL 41, 353). One must not seek the efficient cause of this evil will, because there is none: “non enim est efficiens, sed deficiens, quia nec illa effectio est, sed defectio” “for it is not efficient, but deficient, because it is not an effect, but a defect” (De civitate Dei, XII, 7, PL 41, 355). Evil is not a thing that God has done. It is a lack, a departure from good. Thus, angelic freedom saves at the same time the goodness of the Creator and the reality of guilt.
Thomas accurately describes the nature of the angel’s sin: “The angel, without any doubt, sinned by desiring to be like God,” that is, by seeking to attain blessedness by his own power and nature, instead of through the grace of God (Summa Theologiae I, q. 63, a. 3).
# A Different Reading
Outside of Catholic tradition, there are other readings. The esoteric author Migene González-Wippler, in a popular book about Kabbalah, writes: “The Kabbalists say that angels have a very limited free will and no inclination to practice evil.” And she explains the fall as an excess of zeal: “Angels do not fall because they hate God, but because they want to be closer to him, to be equal to him […]” (González-Wippler, 2006, p. 36). She speaks of wanting to be “equal” to God. Saint Thomas explicitly excludes this desire: the angel knew by natural knowledge that equality with God is impossible, and therefore could not desire it. His sin was to want to be like God in similarity, that is, to attain beatitude by the strength of his own nature and not by grace (Summa Theologiae I, q. 63, a. 3). For the Kabbalistic reading, the fall arises from an excess of zeal and not from a rejection of God. For the Church’s faith, it is the free refusal of a personal creature, and therefore it is a sin.
# Grace and the Definitive Choice
The same angelic nature gave faithful angels and the fallen angels. What separates them is not nature, but response. But the response of the faithful angels was not solely the work of their will. Thomas teaches that the angel could not be converted to happiness «nisi per auxilium gratiae», «unless with the help of grace» (Summa Theologiae I, q. 62, a. 2). Augustine admits two hypotheses: either those who fell received less grace, or, if all were created equally good, those who persevered were «amplius adjuti», «more aided», until they reached that fullness in which they were certain never to fall. In any case, the good will of the angels is a gift of God, who gave them both nature and grace at the same time (De Civitate Dei XII, 9, PL 41, 357).
The choice is definitive. The Catechism teaches that “ὅπερ ἐστὶ τοῖς ἀνθρώποις ὁ θάνατος, τοῦτο τοῖς ἀγγέλοις ἡ ἔκπτωσις. Μετὰ γὰρ τὴν ἔκπτωσιν, οὐκ ἔστιν αὐτοῖς μετάνοια, ὥσπερ οὐδὲ τοῖς ἀνθρώποις μετὰ τὸν θάνατον” (CCC 393), and it quotes Saint John Damascene, who wrote: “What death is to men, so is the fall to the angels. For after the fall, there is no repentance for them, as there is none for men after death” (De fide orthodoxa II, 4, PG 94, 877). Thomas explains why. Man knows by discurring from one thing to another, and thus his will can change. The angel grasps immovably, as we grasp first principles, and therefore his will, once attached, attaches fixedly: his free will is flexible before choice, “but not after” (Summa theologiae I, q. 64, a. 2).
This does not mean that good angels are less free because they can no longer sin. On the contrary: “maior libertas arbitrii est in Angelis, qui peccare non possunt, quam in nobis, qui peccare possumus” “the freedom of will is greater in angels, who cannot sin, than in us, who can sin” (Summa Theologiae I, q. 62, a. 8, ad 3). To be able to turn away from good is not the perfection of freedom, but its defect.
## Frequently Asked Questions
If angels are good by nature, how could they sin?
Because natural goodness is not an impossibility of choice. The Fourth Council of Lateran teaches that they were created good by nature and became evil by their own act: the received nature was good, the act that deformed it was their own (DS 800).
Was the demon created evil?
No. The First Council of Braga (561) condemned those who said that the devil is the principle and substance of evil, and the Fourth Council of Lateran taught positively that God created him good (DS 457 and 800).
Can angels repent?
No. Your choice is irrevocable: what death is to men, fall is to angels (John Damascene, De fide orthodoxa II, 4, PG 94, 877, quoted in part in CCC 393). Saint Thomas explains that the angel, who knows immutably, adheres fixedly to what he has chosen.
Can good angels still fall?
No. The blessed angels see God face to face, and he who sees his own goodness cannot turn away from it (THOMAS AQUINAS, Summa Theologiae I, q. 62, a. 8). They are confirmed in good (q. 64, a. 2).
## References
Augustine of Hippo. On the City of God, Book XII. In: Migne, Jacques-Paul (ed.). Patrologia Latina. Paris: J.-P. Migne, 1845. Vol. 41, col. 353-358.
Dear, Angelo. Angelology in the Tradition of the Church. In: MARCONCINI, Benito et al. Angels and Demons: The Drama of History Between Good and Evil. Bologna: EDB, 1992. p. 127.
CARVALHO, Mário Santiago de. Dictionary of the Philosophical Course of Coimbra. Coimbra: Palimage, 2020. Entry «Libertas», p. 263.
Catechism of the Catholic Church. Nos. 311, 391-393.
Denzinger, Heinrich. Enchiridion Symbolorum Definitionum et Declarationum de Rebus Fidei et Morum. Bilingual edition edited by Peter Hünermann. 2nd ed. Bologna: EDB, 1996. nos. 286, 457, 797, 800.
González-Wippler, Migene. Jesus and the Mystical Cabala: Keys to the Kingdom. São Paulo: Pensamento, 2006.
John Damascene. On Orthodox Faith II, 3-4. In: Migne, Jacques-Paul (ed.). Patrologia Graeca. Paris: J.-P. Migne, 1864. Vol. 94, col. 865-878.
Thomas Aquinas. Summa Theologiae. In: Opera Omnia. Electronic text prepared by Ricardo M. Román. Buenos Aires, 1998. I, q. 59, a. 3, q. 62, a. 2 and 8, q. 63, a. 3, q. 64, a. 2.
Do you want to study angelology with academic rigor?
This article arises from the works in the Locus Mariologicus library. Angelology is one of the disciplines of the Postgraduate Program in Mariology, within a 360-hour curriculum that ranges from Scripture to the Fathers of the Church and the Magisterium.
Responses